Gary's Brew Inc. was created to provide customers access to the finest quality brewing and winemaking ingredients in the Florida Panhandle. Arriving in Pensacola in late 2007, owner and company founder Gary Yetter Sr. discovered that the area lacked the variety of malts, hops, and yeast strains he was accustomed to while living in the Pacific Northwest. After years of going outside the local area to obtain products, Gary decided to launch Gary's Home Brew Supply in August 2013. From it's humble beginnings of having just malts, hops, and yeast, Gary's now carries well over 1500 products in the store, offering customers excellent selection and prices.

Several years after establishing the retail store, craft brewing demand was quickly growing in the area. Gary, his wife Tess, and daughter Crystal decided it was time to expand into the scene. In 2018 they began Gary's Brewery and Biergarten, which officially opened in February 2019. Gary's sons, Gary Jr. and Brian joined the family business shortly after to help with the quickly expanding business.